A Tribute to Clark Pinnock from Edward Fudge

Republished from GracEmail

Grandson of missionaries, young supporter of Wycliffe Bible Translators, veteran of Francis Schaeffer’s L’Abri in Switzerland, doctorate under F.F. Bruce, theology professor at New Orleans Baptist Seminary, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, Regent College, McMaster University, controversial thinker, author and teacher, Clark Pinnock, 73, was all this and so much more last Sunday, when he suddenly fell asleep in Jesus as the result of a massive heart attack at his home in Hamilton, Ontario.

To me, he was an encourager by mail who took time for me when I was wrestling with Reformed theology at Covenant Seminary around 1970 . . . a generous man who gave an endorsement for my first Hebrews commentary in 1974 . . . a friend with whom I visited at Evangelical Theological Society meetings through the years . . . with his wife Dorothy my hospitable hosts overnight once when I was in Canada . . . a later endorser of The Fire That Consumes and an early prominent evangelical spokesperson for the view of hell it presents.

He was a patient man who endured much from a few theological adversaries who were not worthy to tie his shoes . . . a jovial brother who was so tall that Sara Faye had to choose between cutting off his head or my legs when taking our picture in his yard the last time I was privileged to visit with him in person. In short, Clark was one of the most gracious, humble, productive, courageous, open-minded and trying-to-be-like-Jesus men (and theologians) I was ever privileged to know.

Clark Pinnock began teaching theology as a conservative fundamentalist, Calvinist, cessationist (anti-supernatural gifts). Over the years, he left Calvinism, adopted moderate charismatic views (after his nearly-blind eye was miraculously healed in answer to prayer — “one personal experience like that is more persuasive than a whole shelf of books,” he said — or words to that effect), and became a leading voice on the evangelical Left. He wrote books on the Bible, the Holy Spirit, “openness theology” (does God choose not to know the future?), God’s mercy (will He judge people who never hear the gospel by their response to what they did know from God?) and other subjects.

I agreed with many of his controversial views, am not sure of a few others. Whether his opinions were right or wrong, he knew, loved and served the Lord Jesus. His heart was right and that is what counts. Rest in peace, brother Clark. With thousands of others, I appreciate you, grieve your passing, and will miss you for the time I have left here. We look forward to seeing you again in the great Resurrection reunion.

[ Clark Pinnock wrote among other things the conditional / annihiliation view of hell in the book “Four View of Hell“, you can read a review of Four View of Hell. ~ editor]


About Edward Fudge

From time to time we republish gracEmail (a  free, weekday, e-mail ministry of Edward Fudge.) Gracemail is free to reprint, redistribute or otherwise republish on the condition that gracEmail is giving proper credit and not for financial profit. We would encourage you to visit Edward's website at www.EdwardFudge.com and consider subscribing:  Gracemail. Edward Fudge visited New Zealand in 2000 which afterlife.co.nz had the wonderful privilege of helping to host. Review of the Fire that Consumes. Read Edward Fudge's archives on Afterlife.


  1. An excellent tribute. I think it was that graet preacher William Sangster, who said that the nearer he grew to God the further he moved to the left. It would seem that this could have been said of Clark Pinnock, too.

Speak Your Mind